Rent $2,600 or Carry an $800,000 Mortgage? Run Your Own Numbers
By Naveen Vadlamudi, Real Estate Broker, Royal Canadian Realty, Brokerage
A GTA agent's reel went around on November 6 with a simple argument: paying $2,600 a month in rent beats carrying an $800,000 mortgage. It got a lot of attention, because it speaks to a real feeling. Renting feels lighter. A mortgage feels heavy. But a reel is not a financial plan, and the right answer for you is in your own numbers, not in someone else's headline.
Let me be honest about what the reel gets right. Renting at $2,600 a month means no property tax bill, no repair bill, and no surprise when the furnace breaks. You can move when your lease ends. Your monthly cost is fixed and known. For many people, especially if they may change jobs or cities, that flexibility is worth a lot. There is nothing wrong with renting. It is a legitimate choice, not a failure.
What the reel leaves out is what the $2,600 buys you over time. Rent builds nothing for you. Every month, the money is gone. A mortgage payment, on the other hand, has two parts: the interest, which is the cost of borrowing, and the principal, which is money going into your own home. Over years, the principal part builds equity — ownership in an asset that has a value. That is the whole case for buying, and it is a slow case. It does not pay off in six months. It pays off over years.
The other thing the reel leaves out is the market you are actually buying in. TRREB's October 2026 numbers show the average GTA home sold for $1,024,108, at 97 percent of asking, and the average condo sold for $621,400. An $800,000 mortgage does not mean an $800,000 home. It means a home price minus your down payment. Your monthly payment depends on your down payment, your mortgage rate, and your amortization period — the number of years you take to pay it off. Change any one of those and the payment changes a lot. That is why I will not quote you a payment figure in this article. Any number I gave you would be wrong for your situation, and a wrong number is worse than no number.
So here is how to run your own comparison, honestly, in five steps:
Write down your real rent, including parking, utilities and tenant insurance if you pay them. That is your true monthly cost of renting.
Ask a mortgage broker or your bank for a real payment quote on a home at your price, with your down payment, at today's rate, on a 25- or 30-year amortization. Get it in writing.
Add the ownership costs renters do not pay: property tax, home insurance, maintenance fees if it is a condo, and a monthly amount for repairs.
Compare the two monthly totals — but also ask how much of the mortgage payment goes to principal each month. That is the part you keep.
Ask yourself the life question, not just the money question. Will you stay in this home for at least five years? If the answer is no, renting usually wins. If the answer is yes, ownership starts to make sense.
One more thing to check before you decide: what the same money buys in different parts of the GTA. A $700,000 budget goes further in Brampton than it does downtown, and a condo in Mississauga can cost less per month than a similar one closer to the core. Run the numbers for the neighbourhood you actually want to live in, not for the GTA as a whole.
If you want help running your own numbers, or you want to see what a $700,000 budget actually buys right now, call or text me at (416) 837-9696. I will walk you through it, and I will tell you honestly if renting is the better call for you right now.
Further reading: Affordable Brampton Homes for First-Time Buyers Under $700K · Closing Costs in Brampton, Ontario — A Complete Guide
Naveen Vadlamudi is a Real Estate Broker with Royal Canadian Realty, Brokerage, helping buyers and sellers across the Greater Toronto Area. Call or text (416) 837-9696.


Comments
Post a Comment